Skailerskailer

Performance review template

Rate the period on evidence, agree on what comes next

A form a manager and an employee use to look back at a period: rate results against agreed goals, agree on development and set the next goals. It has a rating scale with a definition for every point, a self-assessment, feedback from others, a development plan and notes on EU and UK law.

Performance review

Annual or mid-year review for one employee · meeting 45–60 minutes

01How to use this form

  1. Two weeks before: agree the date and share this form.
  2. At least 3 working days before: the employee shares the self-assessment. The manager gathers evidence from the whole period and asks 2–4 colleagues for input.
  3. In the meeting: the employee speaks first. Then go through goals and competencies, and agree on development and next goals.
  4. Within 5 working days: send the final version. The employee adds comments, and both sign.
  5. Before you finish: book the first check-in.

02Review details

The employee can ask for a copy of this form, and factual errors are corrected on request. Don't record health details or reasons for absence here.

Employee

Job title and level

Team

In this role since (optional)

Reviewer (manager)

Role expectations

Link to the job description or career framework

Review period

Review type

Annual / Mid-year / Other

Meeting date

Who sees this form

Stored in [system]. Visible to the employee, the manager and HR. Kept for [period].

03Rating scale

Rate results and behaviour across the whole period, not just recent weeks, against the agreed goals and with evidence. If hours, scope or time in the role changed, or adjustments were agreed, rate against goals adjusted for that and record the adjustment, not the reason. Don't rate personality, or anything linked to leave, health, pregnancy, age or other protected characteristics.

1

Below expectations

Most agreed goals were not met. A clear improvement plan is needed.

2

Partly meets expectations

Some goals were met. There are specific gaps to close with support.

3

Meets expectations

Agreed goals met at the expected quality. A solid rating, not an average one.

4

Exceeds expectations

Results went beyond the agreed goals or were delivered in harder conditions.

5

Outstanding

Results far beyond the role, with impact the wider company can see.

N/E

Not enough evidence

Too little to go on this period, for example new in the role. Say what evidence you'll collect and by when.

04Goals and results

If a goal changed during the period, note when and who agreed it, and rate against the updated goal.

Goal for this periodHow success was measuredResult and evidenceRating

05Competencies

3 means the description fits. For 4–5, give an example beyond it; for 1–2, an example of the gap. A good example says what happened, what the person did, the result and when.

CompetencyWhat good looks like in this roleExamples from this periodRating
Quality of workWork is accurate, tested and needs little rework.
OwnershipTakes responsibility for outcomes, raises risks early, follows through.
CollaborationWorks well across teams, shares knowledge, helps others succeed.
CommunicationClear in writing and in meetings. Keeps stakeholders informed.
Growth and learningBuilds the skills the role needs and acts on feedback.
[Company value or role skill][What good looks like]
Leading people (managers only)Sets clear goals, gives regular feedback, develops the team.

06Feedback from others (optional)

Ask 2–4 people who worked closely with the employee. Summarise themes, use roles rather than names, and leave out anything they didn't see first-hand.

From (role)What they saw first-handHow collected

07Self-assessment

The employee shares this with the manager at least 3 working days before the meeting. It is kept with the review.

What went well this period, and what are you most proud of?

What was harder than expected, and what did you learn?

Did anything outside your control affect your results?

What support do you need from your manager or the company?

What should your manager start, stop or continue doing?

Where do you want to grow in the next 12 months?

08Manager summary

Main strengths, with examples

Areas to develop, with examples

Overall rating (1–5 or N/E) and how it was reached

09Development plan

Not only courses: projects, mentoring, shadowing and stretch tasks count.

What to developActionsSupport neededHow we'll know it workedBy when

Career interest, in the employee's words (optional)

10Goals for the next period

GoalHow success will be measuredSupports (team or company goal, optional)Due date

First check-in

11Comments and sign-off

If the employee disagrees, they write it under Employee comments and contact [HR contact] within [10 working days].

Was anything in this review new to you?

No / Yes — what:

Employee comments

Pay and promotion

This review is one input into pay decisions under [policy name], which every employee can read at [where]. Promotion readiness is assessed separately against [criteria].

Signatures

Employee ______ Date ______ Manager ______ Date ______ Second reviewer (optional) ______ Date ______

Signing confirms the review was discussed. It does not mean the employee agrees with every point.

Get the template
Use it with your AI

Help me fill in this performance review for one person on my team. Ask me for their goals, results and examples first. Then draft each section in a neutral, evidence-based tone. Don't invent facts: leave a gap where you need my input.

The template goes to your own assistant. Nothing about your employees is sent to us.
Run the whole review cycle in Skailer.Book a demo

What should a performance review include?

  • Review details, and who sees the form
  • A rating scale with a definition for every point
  • Goals with how success was measured and the evidence
  • Competencies with examples
  • The employee's self-assessment and feedback from people they worked with
  • A manager summary with the overall rating and how it was reached
  • A development plan and goals for the next period
  • Comments and sign-off
Skailer

How to run a performance review

01
Two weeks beforeShare the form and ask for the self-assessment. Collect evidence: goal results, examples, feedback from people the employee worked with.
02
Before the meetingDraft the goals, competencies and summary with examples. Decide the rating only from evidence.
03
The meeting, 45–60 minutesStart with the employee's self-assessment, go through goals, then competencies. Agree on the development plan and next goals together.
04
Within five working daysFinalise the form, share it and sign it. Signing confirms the review took place, not that the employee agrees with every point.
05
During the yearCheck goals in one-to-ones every month or quarter, so the next review holds no surprises.

How to rate fairly

  • Use the same criteria and scale for everyone in the same role, and write down what each rating means.
  • Rate the whole period, not the last month. Keep notes during the year.
  • Watch for the halo effect and for putting everyone in the middle.
  • Calibrate: managers compare ratings for similar roles before they are final.
  • If ratings affect pay, tell employees which criteria are used.

Law and compliance

Law checked on 22 November 2026. General information, not legal advice.

EU

Pay. If ratings feed pay rises or promotions, the review criteria work as pay-progression criteria: employers must make them easy for employees to find and keep them objective and gender-neutral. Countries may exempt employers with fewer than 50 workers from this part (Directive (EU) 2023/970, Art. 6). The rule applies once national law does: the deadline was 7 June 2026, and on 22 November 2026 Germany, the Netherlands, France, Ireland and Cyprus had not yet passed theirs.

Data. A review is personal data. The employee can ask for a copy, and you must reply within one month. Collect only what the review needs and keep it for a set period. A decision with significant effects must not rest solely on automated processing (GDPR, Art. 5, 12, 15 and 22).

AI. AI systems used to evaluate employees' performance are high-risk under the AI Act. Their obligations apply from 2 December 2027, including telling employees and their representatives before such a system is used. AI that infers employees' emotions at work has been banned since 2 February 2025 (AI Act, Annex III and Art. 5; dates as amended by Regulation (EU) 2026/1744).

United Kingdom

Acas advises reviewing performance at least once a year and giving the employee a written record (Acas). The Equality Act 2010 bans discrimination in access to promotion, training and other benefits, and requires reasonable adjustments (s.39). From 1 January 2027, employees can claim unfair dismissal after six months' service instead of two years, so written reviews become key evidence in performance-related dismissals (Employment Rights Act 2025, s.25). Appraisal records are employment records: employees can request them, and their disagreement with an assessment can be noted (ICO).

Germany

With a works council, general assessment principles, such as your form and rating scale, need its consent; individual ratings don't. Employees can ask to discuss their assessment and bring a works council member, inspect their personnel file and add their own statement to it (BetrVG §§ 82, 83, 94).

Netherlands

Introducing or changing a staff assessment system needs the works council's consent, as do systems that can monitor performance (WOR, art. 27).

France

The law doesn't require appraisals. If you run them, employees must be told in advance which methods are used, the methods must be relevant to their purpose, results are confidential, and the CSE must be informed and consulted (CNIL). The mandatory career interview is a separate meeting, not an appraisal (service-public.gouv.fr).

Ireland

The Employment Equality Acts ban discrimination on nine grounds in promotion, training and pay, and require reasonable accommodation for employees with a disability (Employment Equality Act 1998). Gender pay gap reporting covers employers with 50 or more employees since 2025 (gov.ie).

Cyprus

Men and women must get equal pay for the same work or work of equal value (Department of Labour Relations). The GDPR applies together with national Law 125(I)/2018 (Data Protection Commissioner). Pay transparency rules are still a draft: a public consultation ran from 5 November to 4 December 2025.

Do this in Skailer
Run review cycles without spreadsheetsSelf, manager, peer and upward reviews on one form, ratings that add up to a final score, and reviews that start on their own, for example at the end of probation.
FAQ

Performance reviews, answered

Most companies run one full review a year and a lighter check-in at mid-year, with goals checked in one-to-ones in between. In the UK, Acas advises at least once a year.

Your demo

Run reviews, goals and surveys in one cycle

We build your company in Skailer. You look around. Like it? Then we talk price.
[email protected]
Just show me the prices first